Is this the time to invest in houses?

I am regularly asked this question - . Should I take my very valuable saving and buy a house, rent it, and hold it for a good return?

The answer is simple; for sure, maybe, probably not, or no way!! I believe that covers it all.

Let us explore these answers and you can decide what to advise or perhaps what to do on your own.

The correct answer directly correlates to risk, expectations, need for money, alternative investments and available time. An investor who wants to buy will have to identify the right asset for a lease / hold strategy and hold it in an investment portfolio as a separate class in the basket. Let’s explore the data and forecasts to help make this decision.

Existing home sale statistics have been rising over the last year but most recently are showing some weaknesses. According to NAR (including SFR’s & Condos) in June sales fell over 5% from May, but are still almost 10% higher then in June 2009. The supply is much higher then we would like to see. But the overall pricing is stable due to such a severe drop. The prices were higher in 10 of 18 metro markets in 2010 versus 2009. Condo values were flat in most markets year to year. In a broad brush approach – northeast values decreased slightly around 1%, Midwest – down 1%, South – unchanged, West was up 1.5%. It does appear that conditions have become more balanced. It is likely that a balance can continue since the tax credit expired and jobs remain a problem. The job situation may be the most important factor in a specific area if we try and forecast future values. This of course is considered along with the release of new distressed inventory by lenders “holding back.” There is also all the recent press about a “double dip” recession projecting future value declines.

Home value volatility and associated risk remain very high. It seems that the stabilization phase with government policy intervention may have run its course now. There is a strong possibility that we could see further price declines as the economy remains weak.

Digging further into values, according to Core Logic’s year to year home price index for June the following is important: The top 5 states with highest appreciation were South Dakota +6.9%, Maine +6.4%, California +5.9%, Virginia +4.7%, Washington DC +4.3%, Top 5 depreciation; Idaho -9.1%, Alabama -3.8%, Oregon -3.5%, Washington -3.4%, New Mexico -3.2%.

There are some factors that show reason for optimism in value expectations. The inventory of new homes being built and released to sell is actually at a very low level. In addition, we have interest rates being offered by lenders that feel like the “limbo” – How low can they go? They are at historical lows and we find 30 year fixed rate loans at around 4.5% to be extremely attractive.

So now having digested the various statistics and investigations, we need to ask if the investor is right for this investment and what a buyer should expect both in return on investment, time commitment, and other issues.

As SFR defaults continue and the housing market seems to stabilize, will SFR lenders increase their strategy to “rent & hold” property rather then dump them or leave them vacant? For many lenders this strategy makes sense even if they are reluctant landlords. A concern for any investor is that these rental homes will become your competitor as well as the multi-family building in the immediate area. Both of these will hold rental values down until the homes are sold and apartments fill-up. This increase in rental unit availabilities can cause a downward spiral for investors holding homes for rent.

As managing director of the Peak Corporate Network, I was recently interviewed by 2 reporters for a cover article in the L.A. Times, August 20th. I was able to provide details due to Peak’s expertise in the default area including our financing products for investors buying houses and our default services. The reporters were responding to reports that institutional investors / funds are jumping into the “trustee sales” investment world. We have seen this directly as we are regularly approached to finance or joint venture in such acquisitions. I believe that the demand to place money is very high now and the property returns on buying at the trustee sale support the “high yield” requirements for many fund managers. I bring this up because it may soon be the case that the way to get the higher “sales price” is at the trustee sales. The same factors that led to previous bubbles with too much money being placed in home loans can lead to too much money chasing the same deals at the footsteps of the courthouse. I can tell you that some of our property loans that have gone to sale have been sold to 3rd parties at prices considerably higher than our analysts advised we wound net at full payoff or as an REO after eviction, repairs and sale costs. This is an interesting phenomenon and will be worth watching. The inventory being acquired may ultimately disappoint the investor and lead to a wave of dumping these homes in 1-2 years.

The days of easy flipping single family homes may be coming to an end according to many savvy realtors and investors. I agree that the markets have in fact “cooled off” as so many remain unemployed and pessimistic. According to one research group, prices will go down even further over the next 18 months by as much as 5-10%. Anyone looking for a short term gain by selling a property is probably heading for trouble. Flipping is going on for sure, but fewer investors will be able to pull it off for a nice profit. Flipping a property requires “cash in hand” with an investment for repairs, holding and selling expenses. The idea of buying it and selling it “as-is” is becoming very difficult to accomplish.

The lenders policies are making it so difficult to close a loan. We regularly make loans for borrowers who simply could not obtain conventional financing in this market even though they are well qualified. Timing is usually the main issue.

Regardless of the roadblocks, investors are buying. The latest NAR figures show that 14% of all transactions in May were by investors. The majority of those being distressed properties that would still be empty if not for the investor.

Is the investment right for you or your client? Investor expectation is the key variable. Banks today are paying from ½ to 2 ½ % for their safer deposits. If we look at real expectations it does not take much of a return to match or beat the alternatives. If one is satisfied with little or no actual net cash flow and is willing to ride out this cycle, we can all agree that values will surely go up from their current levels. The problem of course is where we are in this cycle. I do believe the large downside risk has been stabilized and we are at most within 5-10% of the floor in most major national markets. There could be further declines but some risk is always to be expected and must be assumed. Most properties at these values and current rates cannot throw off cash flow in excess of 5% actual annual returns. In this calculation you have vacancy, cost of funds, repairs, maintenance, taxes, and insurance.

It is a reality that if you are a landlord “things” happen. The same borrowers who had sub-500 fico are now renters. They could not pay their mortgage so why would you expect a good payment record if they are your tenant? This means eviction cost and delays, vacancy, repairs and costs of re-renting. A break in occupancy, even for a short period, will eat up any expected cash flow and probably will result in a “cash call.”

This now brings us to the “time” concern. How available is the investor to handle such issues. Turning the house over to a management company is a solution but it does have a high price tag as well.

Now that we determined that expectations are good and the investor has the capacity to handle the rental I want to give a few tips to help maximize the potential return on investment.

- Talk to top local rental agents about the area and rental conditions.
- Read newspaper ads – How much is being charged for rentals?
- Consider schools and amenities (Shopping / Transportation)
- If Condo – check out HOA restrictions
- Before you rent – maintain it, clean-it up and make it livable.

In conclusion, the concerns are similar if one hopes to flip it or rent and hold. Values are very attractive and if an investor has the wallet to “ride it out” there is a great opportunity to get a very good return at the end. Keep your expectations in line, be ready for surprises and make some money.


Gil Priel, Co-Founder
Peak Corporate Network



Our website: www.PeakCorpNet.com
Join facebook.com/peakcorpnet